Aurora police officer’s actions had ‘cataclysmic effect’ on Elijah McClain, prosecutor says as manslaughter trial opens

By Eric Levenson and Andi Babineau, CNN

(CNN) — Aurora, Colorado, police officer Nathan Woodyard’s actions on the day Elijah McClain was restrained and injected with ketamine in 2019 had a “cataclysmic effect” on the young man, a prosecutor said Tuesday during opening statements in the officer’s manslaughter trial.

Nathan Woodyard, 34, has pleaded not guilty to reckless manslaughter and a lesser included charge of criminally negligent homicide. Woodyard is the third officer tried in connection with the death.

Woodyard and fellow officers “did not listen” when McClain “said ‘I can’t breathe,’ they did not listen to him when he started to drown in his own vomit, and they certainly didn’t pay attention as he got quieter and quieter and quieter,” prosecutor Ann Joyce told jurors Tuesday.

Woodyard placed McClain in a carotid hold – a move in which an officer uses their biceps and forearm to cut off blood flow to a subject’s brain – that left McClain unconscious, according to an indictment.

Woodyard then released the hold, and once McClain regained consciousness, he and other officers restrained him on the ground despite his repeated pleas of “I can’t breathe,” according to the indictment.

Woodyard is currently suspended without pay from the Aurora Police Department.

“Mr. Woodyard did not follow his training and it had a cataclysmic effect on Mr. McClain,” Joyce told the jury.

Defense attorney Megan Downing countered that nothing Woodyard did – not even the carotid hold – caused McClain’s death.

“None of the actions that he took, none of the force that he used, is what caused the death in this case,” Downing told the jury.

“There is one, and only one, undisputed cause of death in this case – no matter how many sequential dots that they will ask you to connect – and that is a lethal injection of ketamine.”

Downing said McClain was alive when Woodyard’s interactions with him stopped. McClain was “alert, conscious, talking to the police – police officers who were not him,” said Downing, motioning to her client.

Woodyard’s use of the carotid hold amounted to an attempt to de-escalate the situation, the defense lawyer insisted. When Woodyard heard another officer say McClain had attempted to grab an officer’s gun, he resorted to non-lethal force rather than reaching for his firearm or taser, according to Downing.

‘He changed Elijah McClain’s situation forever’

The prosecutor showed the jury surveillance video from the gas station McClain had visited immediately before his encounter with police, as well as unenhanced body camera footage from several of the responding officers.

Woodyard violated the Aurora Police Department’s de-escalation policy within seconds of contact with McClain, the prosecutor maintained.

Her opening statement also highlighted the officers’ failure to respond to McClain’s pleas of not being able to breath.

“He’s been trained that if someone says they can’t breathe, just because they’re talking doesn’t mean they’re getting adequate oxygen into their system,” the prosecutor said of the defendant.

Joyce at the end of her statement used Woodyard’s own words from the body camera footage.

“Mr. Woodyard told Elijah McClain, ‘I’m going to have to change this situation.’ And the evidence will be, that Mr. Woodyard was true to his word. He changed Elijah McClain’s situation forever,” she told the jury.

In its opening statement, the defense repeatedly implied that Woodyard’s role in the encounter was involuntary. Downing said he “didn’t choose” to respond to the call or be the primary officer on scene.

“He was assigned to a call which led to a situation he did not expect, he did not want, and he did not control,” she told jurors. “He got a 911 call and he went. And the tragedy is incomprehensible.”

Downing preemptively sought to cast doubt on medical evidence the prosecution is expected to present, calling it “unclear and in dispute.”

“It was not the aspiration that caused Mr. McClain to die. It was not hypoxia. It was not acidosis. And there is no evidence in this case that, but for the ketamine, he would have died,” she said.

Mixed verdicts for two other officers

Last week, a Colorado jury delivered a mixed verdict to two other officers involved in the arrest. Randy Roedema, the senior patrol officer on scene who restrained McClain on the ground, was convicted of criminally negligent homicide and assault, while officer Jason Rosenblatt, who attempted an initial unsuccessful carotid hold, was acquitted of all charges.

Rosenblatt was fired by the police department in 2020. Roedema, who was initially suspended, was fired on Friday following his felony conviction, a city of Aurora spokesperson said Tuesday.

Woodyard’s trial is likely to feature many of the same witnesses and arguments from the trial that just concluded.

The case focuses on the events of August 24, 2019, when officers responded to a call about a “suspicious person” wearing a ski mask, according to the indictment. The officers confronted McClain, a 23-year-old massage therapist, musician and animal lover who was walking home from a convenience store carrying a plastic bag with iced tea. He wore the mask because he was frequently cold, his family has said.

In an interaction captured on body camera footage, police wrestled McClain to the ground and placed him in a carotid hold, and paramedics later injected him with the powerful sedative ketamine. His heart stopped on the way to a hospital, and he was pronounced dead three days later.

Prosecutors initially declined to bring charges, but the case received renewed scrutiny following the nationwide Black Lives Matter protests in spring 2020.

In June 2020, Aurora police and city officials announced changes to police policy, including a ban on carotid holds. Later that month, Colorado Gov. Jared Polis appointed a special prosecutor to reexamine the case, and in 2021 a grand jury indicted three officers and two paramedics in McClain’s death.

Aurora ultimately agreed to pay $15 million to McClain’s family to settle a civil rights lawsuit against the city.

Two paramedics who treated McClain, Jeremy Cooper, 48, and Peter Cichuniec, 50, are set to go on trial in the coming weeks. They have pleaded not guilty to charges of manslaughter and assault.

How the earlier trial went

Roedema and Rosenblatt’s trial began in September and featured testimony from Aurora law enforcement officers who responded to the scene, police training experts and doctors who analyzed how McClain died.

The defense did not call any witnesses, and the two did not testify in their own defense.

The prosecution played body-camera footage of the arrest and said the footage showed officers used excessive force for no reason. McClain repeatedly said he couldn’t breathe, yet the officers did not tell that to anyone on the scene.

The officers “chose force at every opportunity” instead of trying to de-escalate the situation as they’re trained, prosecutor Duane Lyons told the court at closing arguments.

In contrast, Rosenblatt’s attorney, Harvey Steinberg, painted his client as a “scapegoat” and said it’s the paramedics’ responsibility to evaluate a patient’s medical condition. Roedema’s attorney, Don Sisson, said his client’s use of force was justified because McClain resisted arrest. He said McClain had been given 34 commands to either “stop” or “stop fighting.”

The precise cause of McClain’s death was also a key focus of the trial. Prosecutors argued that the police restraint contributed to McClain’s death, while defense attorneys said the paramedics’ decision to inject a large dose of ketamine was to blame.

An initial autopsy report said McClain’s cause of death was “undetermined.” However, an amended report publicly released in 2022 listed “complications of ketamine administration following forcible restraint” as the cause of death.

The mixed verdict for Roedema and Rosenblatt drew split responses.

Sheneen McClain, Elijah McClain’s mother, told CNN affiliate KUSA after the verdict, “This is not justice.” She said Roedema’s guilty verdict is “not enough,” adding the officer was not acting alone in what led to her son’s death.

Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser said he hoped the verdict can help the community heal.

“Everyone in Colorado, everyone in the United States, no matter who you are, is accountable under the law. Hopefully today’s verdict can be a sign for healing for the Aurora community and for our state,” Weiser said.

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2023 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.

CNN’s Ray Sanchez and Taylor Romine contributed to this story.